These two questions get asked together constantly, and the honest answer is that most Adventists refrain from both, though for different reasons and with different levels of conviction. Alcohol is an unambiguous no. Coffee is treated more cautiously than many people expect, even though it isn't held to quite the same absolute standard.
Alcohol: A Clear, Long-Standing Conviction
Total abstinence from alcohol is a clear, settled position among Adventists, not a matter of personal preference the way some other lifestyle questions are. "Wine is a mocker, strong drink is raging: and whosoever is deceived thereby is not wise" (Proverbs 20:1), and Paul is direct: "be not drunk with wine, wherein is excess" (Ephesians 5:18). This isn't just custom — it's written directly into the vows every new member affirms at baptism, which ask whether the candidate will honor God by "abstaining . . . from the use, manufacture, or sale of alcoholic beverages" (Seventh-day Adventist Church Manual, Baptismal Vow 10). Drinking alcohol isn't treated as an open question within Adventist practice.
Where That Conviction Comes From
The roots run through the 19th-century temperance movement that shaped early Adventism, combined with Paul's question, "know ye not that your body is the temple of the Holy Ghost?" (1 Corinthians 6:19), explored further in Body as a Temple: The Adventist Health Message. Alcohol's capacity to impair judgment and create dependency made it an early, clear-cut application of that stewardship principle, and the conviction never really loosened over time the way some other lifestyle questions have.
“The only safe course is to touch not, taste not, handle not, tea, coffee, wines, tobacco, opium, and alcoholic drinks.”
— Ellen G. White, Testimonies for the Church, vol. 3, p. 488
What About Paul's Advice to Timothy?
This is the passage skeptics raise most often: "Drink no longer water, but use a little wine for thy stomach's sake and thine often infirmities" (1 Timothy 5:23). Read in context, it's narrow, personal medical advice for one man's specific stomach ailment, not a general endorsement of drinking. The wording limits it on both ends — "a little wine," not unrestricted use, prescribed "for thy stomach's sake," not for enjoyment. It sits alongside, not against, Scripture's many separate warnings against drunkenness (Proverbs 20:1; Ephesians 5:18). Ancient wine was also commonly diluted and far less consistently fermented than modern alcohol, and clean water wasn't always reliably available. One narrow medicinal exception for one person's health condition was never meant to unsettle a principle stated so clearly and so often elsewhere.
Coffee and Caffeine: Refrained From, Though Less Absolutely
Coffee gets treated more cautiously than many outsiders expect. Historically, Ellen White's health writings discouraged caffeine alongside alcohol and tobacco, and most Adventists still follow that counsel today, avoiding coffee, or at least treating it as something to limit, rather than drinking it freely. It doesn't carry quite the same absolute, non-negotiable status alcohol does, and it isn't treated as a test of fellowship — some Adventists do drink it without controversy — but refraining from it, not drinking it, remains the more common practice.
Why the Two Get Treated Differently
The distinction isn't arbitrary, and it shows up in the church's own official language too. The baptismal vow explicitly names alcohol, tobacco, and drug misuse as things a member commits to abstain from — it says nothing about coffee or caffeine at all. Scripture warns specifically and repeatedly against drunkenness and impaired judgment, categories alcohol clearly falls into. Caffeine's downsides — sleep disruption, dependency, jitteriness — are real, but they're a matter of degree and moderation rather than the kind of intoxication Scripture explicitly names as dangerous. That difference in kind, not just degree, is why alcohol carries an absolute, settled answer while coffee carries a strong, widely followed caution that still leaves some room for individual conscience.
What About Tea, Soda, and Energy Drinks?
The same caution extends to other caffeinated drinks. Many Adventists avoid caffeine sources fairly consistently, reaching for decaf, herbal tea, or water instead; others allow themselves moderate caffeine without much concern. Energy drinks tend to draw more caution across the board, less because of caffeine specifically and more because of their sugar content and marketing toward excess.
The Bigger Principle Behind Both
Underneath both questions sits the same test: "whether therefore ye eat, or drink, or whatsoever ye do, do all to the glory of God" (1 Corinthians 10:31). That standard settles alcohol clearly and absolutely, and it's the same standard that leads most Adventists to limit or avoid coffee too, even without an identical, absolute rule behind it.
Common Questions
Essentially never, as a matter of practice. Total abstinence is a clear, settled position among Adventists worldwide, not treated as a matter of personal preference.
Yes. Every candidate for baptism is asked whether they will honor God by "abstaining . . . from the use, manufacture, or sale of alcoholic beverages" (Seventh-day Adventist Church Manual, Baptismal Vow 10). The same vow says nothing about coffee or caffeine.
No, but most Adventists refrain from it anyway, following the church's long-standing health counsel. It isn't treated as sin or a test of fellowship the way alcohol comes close to being, but avoiding or limiting it remains the more common practice, not the exception.
Yes, but as narrow, personal medical advice for a specific stomach ailment (1 Timothy 5:23), not a general endorsement of drinking. It doesn't cancel Scripture's many separate, repeated warnings against drunkenness.
Scripture specifically and repeatedly warns against drunkenness and impaired judgment, which alcohol produces. Caffeine's downsides are real but are a matter of moderation and dependency rather than that same kind of intoxication.
Water, herbal tea, decaf, and fruit juices are common. Most limit or avoid caffeine as a matter of course, though some drink coffee or regular tea in moderation as a matter of personal conviction.
Keep Exploring
See how this fits into the wider health message.
